A Tennessee county school board voted unanimously Wednesday to censure a member who told a student, “God, you’re hot” at a public board meeting last week.
Subscribe to read this story ad-free
Get unlimited access to ad-free articles and exclusive content.
The Washington County Board of Education approved the censure during an emergency meeting, following public calls to remove board member Keith Ervin and Superintendent Jerry Boyd.
In a board meeting April 2, which was livestreamed, Ervin told a female high school student next to him: “God, you’re hot. Do you know that? Damn. Where do you go to school at?”
The girl, who is a student member of the board, had just wrapped up asking questions about career and technical education when Ervin put his arm around her and hugged her from the side and made the comment.
Some other board members at the table lightly laughed, and the meeting went on.
A school board censure is a formal condemnation of a member’s conduct but doesn’t remove a person from office.
At Wednesday’s meeting, several locals spoke about their anger and disappointment and called for Ervin to step down and for the board to take accountability.
Ervin read a prepared speech in which he said he hadn’t intended to offend anyone and claimed that his “hot” comment was misconstrued.
“Obviously I’ve seen the clip. Look, I get it, if that’s all you’re seeing, I understand why people are reacting the way they are,” he said. “But that’s not the full conversation, not even close. Last week at the board meeting I wanted to congratulate a student who did a great job sharing thoughts with all that was in the room.”
“When I mentioned she was hot, I meant she was on a roll, it was nothing to do with her appearance,” he continued. “As a lifetime supporter of David Crockett High school, I was especially surprised to learn that’s where she went to school.
He went on to say that the clip of his comment that has gone viral was just a few seconds out of the two-hour meeting and that the full video of the meeting gives context.
“There was no disrespect mean,t and I apologize to her and her family for my comment reacting in the public for the incredible job she did as a student board member,” he said.
As he was wrapping up, a man in the audience yelled, “I watched it; you’re a liar!” referring to the full video of the meeting.
“I’d just like folks to take a look at it before jumping to conclusions. The video speaks for itself,” Ervin said, concluding his speech.
“It sure does!” a woman in the room shouted.
Boyd attended Wednesday’s meeting, sitting among school board members, but didn’t speak.
Board members shared short statements.
Member Whitney Riddle called for Ervin to step down over the “inappropriate and unacceptable” comments, to raucous applause from audience members.
Board member Eric Barnes said: “Mr. Ervin, I can’t judge your intent or your heart. But I was here. I saw the actions. They were inappropriate; we all understand that. This has obviously drawn a lot of unwanted attention to this school system, it’s hurtful to the school system, and I think the right thing for you to do is resign.”
Other members said they believed Ervin misspoke and didn’t have ill intent, and they cited his yearslong tenure in the elected board seat.
At the end, there was a motion to censure Ervin, and all board members voted yes, with Ervin abstaining.
Ervin and the board didn’t immediately respond to requests for further comment.
The video of the April 2 meeting had sparked local outrage, and a petition seeking to remove Ervin and Boyd had garnered thousands of signatures as of Wednesday.
“Jerry Boyd’s passive acceptance of Keith Ervin’s comment reveals a disturbing lack of leadership and judgment,” the petition said. “It is imperative that we take action now to hold these officials accountable.”
The board previously condemned Ervin’s comments as “grossly inappropriate.”
“Mr. Ervin has explained that he meant nothing offensive and that we have simply misunderstood his intentions,” the board told NBC affiliate WSMV of Nashville in a statement. “Mr. Ervin knows his own intentions, but the rest of us have to judge his words and his actions. What we saw was shocking. He objectified and diminished a young woman publicly. No explanation can justify that.”
Community members were fierce with outrage during the public comment part of Wednesday’s meeting.
“Mr. Ervin, you have broken the community’s trust and confidence and the school board’s ability to do its job,” a woman said.
Another woman said: “If that had been a male student next to you, you wouldn’t have done that. You wouldn’t have put your arm around her and said, ‘Oh, yeah!’ The days of men thinking it’s OK for you to put your arm around a female, around their waist, or hug them, get in their face, are over.”
A man received loud applause when he asked: “Would you want your kid around that guy without a camera around? I wouldn’t.”
Ervin was elected in 2006 to represent the First District on the board. He is described as a self-employed dairy farmer and father of two daughters, according to the board’s website.